Top

White House Office of Science and Technology Subcommittee on Forensic Science Report

The National Science and Technology Council has just released a new report entitled “Strengthening the Forensic Sciences.” This is a report summarizing the work of the White House Office of Science and Technology Subcommittee on Forensic Sciences’ efforts to respond to the NAS report released in 2009.It is relevant to all who practice in the forensic sciences, and is largely centred on the accreditation and certification of forensic sciences.

This makes the assumption that the certify bodies, and the forensic sciences themselves are appropriate and fit for purpose.  It is somewhat disappointing that the report does not seek to address the scientific weaknesses of forensic sciences – and perhaps even suggest that there may be resources available to support research.  Perhaps this is the only way that we will truly  strengthen forensic science – by developing and enhancing the underlying evidence base for much of what is presented in Court. shutterstock_174329015

Proficiency testing

The section on proficiency testing that gets closest to what the original NAS report was concerned over, and they rightly point out that proficiency testing:

The benefits of discipline-specific proficiency testing include:

  • Demonstration of a laboratory’s ability to satisfy, on an ongoing basis, accreditation or
  • certification requirements and ongoing competency;
  • Comparison of an individual’s or a laboratory’s performance with that of another;
  • Identification of methodological problems, transcription error patterns, or other undetected
  • performance weaknesses and initiation of actions for improvement;
  • Establishment of the effectiveness and comparability of test or measurement methods and,
  • through the provision of metrics that could be analyzed, interpreted, and published, facilitation
  • of further standardization of laboratory procedures and best practices;
  • Validation of uncertainty claims;
  • Enhancement of stakeholder confidence in the reliability of forensic science providers’ work
  • products.

Relevance to odontology

There is no formal proficiency testing in either the UK or the US currently – although Diplomates of the ABFO are examined and then re-certified there are no published results from such tests and the threshold for “passing” is not published.  Experts are unable to point to published and presented details of their proficiency measured against best practice and also against average performance.  There is a need for all odontologists to embrace this transparency of ability measurement, and, in doing so, improve the quality of practice and evidence across the discipline.

You can download the report here .

 

Powered by WordPress . Designed by Woo Themes