Top

State v Prade – Court Reverses & another appeal due

Douglas Prade
Douglas Prade

Prade, a 15 year veteran of Ohio police has spent nearly 15 years in jail for his ex-wife’s murder.

Family
Family

Margo Prade’s sister speaks to the media following the return to custody of her ex-husband.

Back to jail
Back to jail

Prade taken in custody – he was later released on Thursday 20th March while the Supreme Court considers what to do next.

Yvonne Prade
Yvonne Prade

Sitting with his sister Prade will now be free while the Supreme Court again considers the impact of the DNA testing and bitemark evidence.

Lisa Gates
Lisa Gates

Prade is shown here with his attorney who has spearheaded the appeals on his behalf.

..

A long and lengthy legal battle has a new chapter today (14th March 2014) as the State of Ohio Court of Appeal reverses the decision of a lower Court and refuse an appeal brought by Douglas Prade against his aggravated murder conviction. The trial court stated:

[b]ite mark evidence….provided the basis for the guilty verdict

This is a fascinating case and features a controversial bitemark and a number of experts who have testified over the years in the case.  One of the originally testifying dentists – Lowell Levine features in this case and for this appeal the Court heard from Dr Frank Wright and Dr Mary Bush.  Each had differing views over the utility of the bitemark.

The trial court noted that neither Dr. Bush, nor Dr. Wright had tendered an opinion with regard to the specific bite mark left on Margo, but that both had criticized either the science behind bite mark identification or the bite mark identification testimony that had been admitted at Prade’s trial. The trial court determined that “both experts’ opinions call into serious question the overall scientific basis for bite-mark identification testimony.

Interestingly the bitemark was also a source of DNA.  The appeal was based on the fact that analysis of this could not identify Prade, indeed the court found that “..without a  – however, the complexities of the analysis, and the risk of contamination appear to have negated this evidence.

When examining the bitemark evidence the judges state that, as in many other cases, the trier of fact (jury) were given all the details of the bitemark, that there were varied opinions provided, and that they were clear that bitemarks had been wrongly analysed in the past:

As for the dental experts, the jury was essentially presented with the entire spectrum of opinions on the bite mark at trial. That is, one expert testified that Prade was the biter, one testified that the bite mark was consistent with Prade’s dentition, but that there was not enough there to make any conclusive determination, and the third testified that Prade lacked the ability to bite anything. Moreover, the expert who definitively said Prade was the biter, Dr. Marshall, also said that the expert who determined a definitive inclusion could not be made (Dr. Levine) was “one of the leading bite[]mark experts in the country.” The jury also heard testimony during cross-examination that dental experts often disagree and that bite mark testimony has led to wrongful convictions. In short, the jury had much of the same information before it at trial that the experts at the PCR stage presented and, in light of all that information, found Prade guilty

In essence there is a view that the bitemark evidence – for better or worse, was placed into context and the jury should apply an appropriate weight given the differences of opinions and the conclusions reached. It should also be noted that the DNA analysts also reached different conclusions when considering why Prade was excluded as the source.  So even DNA is not impervious to the mixed opinions of testify experts. You can download the entire judgement here

A further development on the 20th March is that, just hours after he was taken in to custody, the Supreme Court issued a ruling that led to Douglas Prade’s release.

“This has been a crazy, day but you guys forget I spent 15 years in hell,” Prade said upon his release Thursday.

The former Akron police captain was declared not guilty of his wife’s murder more than one year ago and was released from prison. But Wednesday, the 9th District Court of Appeals issued a ruling saying his release was a mistake, and he was taken back into custody Thursday morning. Prade appealed that ruling to the Supreme Court, which issued a stay in his case on Thursday. Prade was released — again — Thursday at around 2:30 p.m., and is to remain free while the Supreme Court reviews his case.

A status hearing took place at 9 a.m. Thursday at the Summit County Common Pleas Court. Prade arrived about a half hour before.  His sister Yvonne was with him along with Lisa Gates, one of his attorneys. If prosecutors have their way, he will head back to prison to serve out the rest of his life sentence. Prade spent 14 years behind bars after he was convicted in the 1997 shooting death of his wife, Dr. Margo Prade, outside her Akron medical office. Last year, a Summit County judge ordered his release from prison after his attorneys argued the was DNA evidence on Dr. Prade’s lab coat did not belong to Douglas Prade.

When this piece of evidence went back to the jury, we don’t know if jurors handled it, we don’t know if that was jurors’ DNA on it,” said Brad Gessner, assistant county prosecutor. “We know that when the FBI initially tested this, there was no saliva on it.  So as the court said, how do you argue about all of this saliva all these years later when there was none there to start with?”

The 9th District Court of Appeals ruled that the Summit County judge who declared Prade not guilty “abused her discretion” and said that Prade’s DNA results were “questionable” and only “generated more questions than answers.”

My sister is gone and she’s resting in peace and we’re still suffering, but for them to let Douglas out like they did, I was just so outdone the way they let him out,” said Veronica Sadler, Margo Prade’s sister.

 

 

Powered by WordPress . Designed by Woo Themes