The report and recommendations of the
Fingerprint Inquiry
in the case of Shirley McKie has finally emerged. The report will join the very few that will have international and important repercussions for forensic practice. The NAS report criticised some elements of fingerprint analysis and bitemark analysis and therefore there is an interest from odontologists concerning this. The main conclusions of the enquiry found that:
- opinions are subjective and opinions of certainty are inherently unscientific (Key recommendations 1, 2, and 3)
- honest error is nevertheless an error (Key findings 4 -7)
- experts should record and properly disclose all of the basis of their opinion to enable a court to understand it and the defence to assess it (Recommendations 60, 61 and 64)
- this includes listing all variables considered and stating whether the conclusion has been reached through training and personal experience or on any other basis such as statistical analysis (Recommendation 5); this is similar to the ruling of the Appeal Court of England and Wales regarding footwear evidence ( R v T )
- expert opinion should be informed by proper academic study of the subject (Recommendations 16-18)
It is clear that these principles can and will be expected to apply to all forensic practice and bitemark evidence in particular. The AAFS 2012 meeting again looked at elements of the NAS report and how odontology was striving to meet it. It is likely that had a “Bitemark enquiry” been commissioned, it may well have reached similar conclusions.